Parliament as it happened: 'Wasted' Winter Session concludes, Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha pass Disabilities Bill

Rajya Sabha adjourned till Friday without any discussion on triple talaq bill

Govt requests to take up GST bill first as Dy Chairman ruled Triple Talaq bill can’t be taken for passage without first building consensus in House

Sukhendu Shekhar Roy of TMC rejects govt allegation that suggested composition of Standing Committee was not inclusive

Roy, responding to Jaitley’s objection that the Select Committee suggested by him did not reflect the nature of the House, Roy said that he had included members from all parties who were willing to send the bill to the Standing Committee. However, BJP members were not included because the government was not willing to send the bill to the committee. Roy added that if the BJP is interested in sending the Bill for further scrutiny, he has no objection to ammend the list to include its members too.

PJ Kurien says resolution was admitted because Chairman himself allowed it

Kurien said that the Leader of the House is a very learned advocate himself and all points raised by him are of relevance. The rule he quotes that a prior notice should be given is also correct, he said. “However, the same rule adds that the Chairman has the power to admit such a motion and which is why I cannot overrule it. It is now admitted and hence is the property of the House, only members can amend it,” Kurien said on Jaitley’s objection over the Opposition motion seeking triple talaq bill be sent to Standing Committee.

Uproar in Rajya Sabha after opposition's motion on #TripleTalaqBill, opposition has demanded the bill be sent to select committee

— ANI (@ANI) January 4, 2018

Arun Jaitley raises objection on point of order requesting bill be sent to Standing Committee

Jaitley said that the previous precedents show that any amendments or motions should be introduced with prior notice. He said that the Opposition’s demand to send the bill to Select Committee was invalid. He also raised objection on the suggestion on members of Select Committee made by Anand Sharma. 

He said that a committee should reflect the nature of the House, which the list of suggestions given by Sharma does not. Sharma’s suggestion did not include names from the BJP.

Govt bill is incomplete, will finish Muslim women, says LoP Ghulam nabi Azad in RS

Ghulam Nabi Azad stood up as the bill was taken up for discussion and said that none of the parties are in opposition of the bill in essence. However, he said that the government’s bill will “finish Muslim women” instead of saving them. 

“If you will put their husbands in jail, who will provide for them, who will pay for their children,” Azad asked as he reiterated that Congress leader Anad Sharma’s suggestion to send it to Standing Committee should be taken into consideration.

Rajya Sabha begins debate on the triple talaq Bill

BJP president Amit Shah reaches Parliament 

BJP president Amit Shah reached Parliament, to make his Parliamentary debut in Rajya Sabha today 
 

#ParlWinterSession -- BJP President Amit Shah reaches Parliament, to make his Parliamentary debut in Rajya Sabha today
Image: ANI pic.twitter.com/LUlaLMAjsL

— News18 (@CNNnews18) December 15, 2017

Mallikarjun Kharge appeals govt to create healthy atmosphere for debate 

Congress leader Mallikarjun Kharge said govt should should respect Opposition and create an atmosphere for healthy debate during Parliament Winter Session.

Narendra Modi hopes for positive debate 

“I hope that Winter Session will be fruitful. I expect that Winter Session will proceed in a positive way. I hope that Winter Session debate will strengthen democracy. I believe that to take the country ahead this Winter Session debate will be useful, " said Modi as Winter Session sets to begin.

Narendra Modi sought cooperation of all political parties at all party meet 

On the eve of Winter Session, two all-party meetings were convened, first by the ruling NDA and the other by Lok Sabha speaker Sumitra Mahajan. At the all-party meeting Modi requested all parties for cooperation in order to make Parliament session a fruitful one. 

Mahajan met the leaders from all parties on Thursday over dinner.

Winter Session of Parliament begins today: There are 14 sittings this session

#WinterSession begins today. There are 14 sittings this session.

— PRS Legislative (@PRSLegislative) December 15, 2017

निशक्त व्यक्ति अधिकार विधेयक, 2016 दिव्यांगो को सशक्त बनाने का विधेयक है इसलिए विपक्ष इसका समर्थन कर रहा है : @kcvofficial #LokSabha

— Lok Sabha TV (@loksabhatv) December 16, 2016

Lok Sabha debates Disability Bill

Possibly the only work that was undertaken during Winter Session, MPs in Lok Sabha are debating the Disability Bill and are planning to pass it. Today is the last day of Winter Session. 

Rajya Sabha was adjourned sine die earlier today. 

निशक्त व्यक्ति अधिकार विधेयक, 2016 पर लोक सभा में चर्चा चल रही है..#LokSabha

— Lok Sabha TV (@loksabhatv) December 16, 2016

Speaker Sumitra Mahajan disallows demand for adjournment motions in Lok Sabha

लोक सभा अध्यक्ष ने विपक्ष के सभी स्थगन प्रस्ताव किए खारिज #LokSabha

— Lok Sabha TV (@loksabhatv) December 16, 2016

Peace prevailed only when obituaries were read out: Hamid Ansari

The Rajya Sabha on Friday concluded its winter session after an emotional speech by the Chairman as the house was adjourned sine die.
 

“Regular and continuous disruptions signify this session… The rules about displaying placards and shouting slogans were ignored by all sections of the house,” Rajya Sabha Chairman Hamid Ansari said in his closing statement before adjourning the house.
 

Peace prevailed only when obituaries were read out, he added.

Meeting of Congress leaders with PM Narendra Modi earlier today (pic source: PMO) pic.twitter.com/BsO77aW5Le

— ANI (@ANI) December 16, 2016

All sections of the house(Rajya Sabha) need to introspect on the distinction between dissent,disruption and agitation: VP Hamid Ansari

— ANI (@ANI) December 16, 2016

Rajya Sabha adjourned sine die

— ANI (@ANI) December 16, 2016

Hamid Ansari raps MPs on last day of Winter Session

PM Narendra Modi attends Rajya Sabha #wintersession pic.twitter.com/nrc9XWB4Vj

— ANI (@ANI) December 16, 2016

Lok Sabha starts at 11 am, gets adjourned at 11.03 am till 12 pm

Lok Sabha adjourned till 12 pm #wintersession

— ANI (@ANI) December 16, 2016

Congress delegation gives memorandum to PM Narendra Modi on farmers loan waiver issue

— ANI (@ANI) December 16, 2016

Delhi: BJP leaders leave after the party's Parliamentary meet pic.twitter.com/atb9xzLOZA

— ANI (@ANI) December 16, 2016

Prime Minister Narendra Modi appealed to people of India that digital economy should be a way of life,it will be transparent and effective, Parliamentary Affairs Minister Ananth Kumar said. 

PM appealed to people of India that digital economy should be a way of life,it will be transparent and effective: Ananth Kumar pic.twitter.com/OMw5x45HxA

— ANI (@ANI) December 16, 2016

PM ne kaha aaj 16 tarikh Bangla vimochan diwas hai, tab vipaksh ne saboot nahi manga tha,lekin aaj vipaksh saboot mangta hai:Ananth Kumar

— ANI (@ANI) December 16, 2016

PM ne kaha pehle satta paksh ghotale karta tha, aaj ke din satta paksh black money ko lekar kaam kar raha hai: Ananth Kumar

— ANI (@ANI) December 16, 2016

Rahul Gandhi will meet with Narendra Modi shortly

Two days after serious corruption allegations against the prime minister, Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi, along with other Congress leaders, will meet Narendra Modi shortly.

Reports said that the meeting is about waiving off farmer loans.

Congress leaders including Rahul Gandhi to meet PM Narendra Modi shortly

— ANI (@ANI) December 16, 2016

Narendra Modi to address BJP members today

The last day of the Winter Session of Parliament is setup for a big tussle between the government and the Opposition as both try to break the deadlock.

The BJP’s Parliamentary Party meeting to discuss the strategy to counter the Opposition’s charges against the government is currently underway. Prime Minister Narendra Modi is set to address the gathering.

Opposition leaders are scheduled to meet the President and PM Modi to push for a way to break the deadlock.

Delhi: BJP Parliamentary Party meeting underway. (Inside visuals) pic.twitter.com/yoz4KXp8Tu

— ANI (@ANI) December 16, 2016

When I inquired about his (LK Advani) health, he said my health is okay but the Parliament's health is not: TMC MP Idris Ali pic.twitter.com/OMmAQNJxP4

— ANI (@ANI) December 15, 2016

Advani ji said "Koi jeete yaa haarey, iss sab hungame se sansad ki haar ho rhi hai,speaker se baat karke kal charcha honi chahiye":Idris Ali

— ANI (@ANI) December 15, 2016

LK Advani told me that he feels like resigning, adding "had Atal ji been in the Parl today, he would have been upset": TMC MP Idris Ali

— ANI (@ANI) December 15, 2016

I feel like resigning, says LK Advani

Senior BJP leader LK Advani told Home Minister Rajnath Singh to intervene and stop disruptions in both Houses of Parliament.  Expressing his unhappiness, Advani allegedly said that he “feels like resigning”.

Advani also added that “had Atal ji been in Parliament today, he would have been upset.”

Winter Session a failure – Opposition meets President Pranab

Taking their protest on demonetisation to President Pranab Mukherjee’s doorsteps, Opposition parties sought a meeting with the president to convey the problems caused by the measure to the common man and “over not being” allowed to speak in Parliament. At a meeting of the opposition held in the chamber of Leader of Opposition in Rajya Sabha Ghulam Nabi Azad, representatives of various parties decided to raise with the President the problems of the common people, including the poor and farmers arising out of demonetisation.

Leaders of various parties said the entire opposition has decided to approach the President to “complain” against the ruling party for not allowing them to speak in Parliament. The leaders said they were elected representatives of the country and had every right to speak in Parliament and it was “unconstitutional” not to allow them to speak in both Houses. Sources said time is being sought from the President till Friday and all opposition parties were ready to raise the issue unitedly before him.

Sources said that it was also decided in the meeting to raise the plight of farmers and common people in both Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha and demand a loan waiver for farmers. Representatives of Congress, Trinamool Congress, BSP, SP, JD-U, CPI, CPI-M, NCP, DMK and All India United Democratic Front (AIUDF) were present in today’s meeting.

With inputs from PTI

Answers on #Agusta have been given in Parliament before, rest inquiry is on.Govt doesn't want to discuss #Demonitization: Mallikarjun Kharge pic.twitter.com/8AQfJ9oA7e

— ANI (@ANI) December 15, 2016

Rajya Sabha adjourned till 2 pm

Lok Sabha adjourned for the day

Mallikarjun Kharge: We want debate, ruling BJP is obstructing discussion

Members create ruckus in Lok Sabha after Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha Mallikarjun Kharge gets up to speak. It is shameless that Parliamentarians behave the way Lok Sabha is functioning. 

Unnecessary yelling, screaming and obstructing debate and discussion has become usual in the Lower House. Parliamentary Affairs Minister Ananth Kumar raises AgustaWestland issue in Lok Sabha as Opposition demands to debate demonetisation.

Rajya Sabha was earlier adjourned after uproar as GN Azad raised farmers issue on demonetization & treasury benches raised #AgustaWestland

— ANI (@ANI) December 15, 2016

Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha resume, so does ruckus

Meri BJP ko salah hai ke Rahul ji ko itne halke mein na le. Jab Rahul ji bole the Modi ji ko apne suit-boot bechne pade the: Raj Babbar pic.twitter.com/6xwFP8eIlh

— ANI (@ANI) December 15, 2016

Rahul Gandhi ko koi gambheerta se leta nahin hai, kyunki wo swayam gambheer nahin hain: Hansraj Ahir, MoS Home pic.twitter.com/y2yRJ7pLYd

— ANI (@ANI) December 15, 2016

Let me speak: Rahul Gandhi

After a sudden press conference where the Congress vice-president claimed that he had information on ‘personal corruption’ the prime minister, Rahul Gandhi on Thursday demanded that he be allowed to speak in the House. 

Let me speak, I will speak: Congress vice president Rahul Gandhi

— ANI (@ANI) December 15, 2016

Parliament logjam continues even though 2 days left for Winter Session

Merely two days are remaining for the Winter Session to wrap up, but both the Houses showed absolutely no concern for the fact that the session has been a complete washout until now. The Lok Sabha got adjourned within minutes of commencing and Rajya Sabha a few minutes after. Both Opposition and BJP sparred over the issue of demonetisation and Rahul Gandhi’s jibe at Narendra Modi on Wednesday.

Earlier in the day, senior BJP ministers, including Venkaiah Naidu and Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi had met with Prime Minister Narendra Modi ahead of the session and the Opposition parties met with President Pranab Mukherjee.

BJP and Opposition both stall Rajya Sabha

Helpless deputy chairman PJ Kurien begs for MPs to sit down as Congress and BJP leaders spar over Ghulam Nabi Azad’s speech on demonetisation.

“I have to adjourn.. what should I do?” asks Kurien. “This is for the first time in history of India that it’s the ruling party that’s not letting the House to function,” says Azad. 

Uproar by opposition in Rajya Sabha, says Govt not letting the house function

— ANI (@ANI) December 15, 2016

This is for the first time in history of India that it's the ruling party that's not letting the House to function: Ghulam Nabi Azad in RS pic.twitter.com/laIq9yytR7

— ANI (@ANI) December 15, 2016

Maine notice diya hai kisaanon ka karza maaf karne ke liye, BJP sarkaar kisaan virodhi sarkaar hai: GN Azad in Rajya Sabha

— ANI (@ANI) December 15, 2016

BJP protest in Rajya Sabha

Senior BJP leader Venkaiah Naidu and Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi object to leader of opposition Ghulam Nabi Azad speaking in the Upper House. Kurien asks BJP members to sit down. Amid slogans of “Agusta Agusta”, BJP leaders demanded to know what is the topic of discussion?

Kurien allows Azad to speak.

Members protest in Rajya Sabha

Kurien: “I have given the floor to Leader of Opposition. That’s the tradition. Let’s follow it. Please sit down.”

Lok Sabha adjourned till 12 pm amid massive uproar

BJP raises AgustaWestland scam in Lok Sabha. Amid massive uproar, Sumitra Mahajan adjourns the House till 12 pm.

Congress has made a grave mistake by raising their finger against me,they will pay the price for their lifetime,I'm telling you:Kiren Rijiju pic.twitter.com/snpIH99nzU

— ANI (@ANI) December 15, 2016

Notice in Rajya Sabha for discussion on corruption allegation against Rijiju

Congress leader Anand Sharma gave notice in Rajya Sabha for discussion on Kiren Rijiju’s alleged involvement in Arunachal hydro scam issue.

Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha start

Rajya Sabha adjourned till tomorrow amid uproar over Kiren Rijiju's alleged involvement in corruption related to Arunachal Hydro Project

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

Both sides are indisciplined, what can I do? asks Kurien

It seemed like the members in the Upper House were just waiting to pass one single Bill this Winter Session. Soon after Kurien praised the members of the Upper House for being disciplined, ruckus over alleged corruption allegations on Kiren Rijiju took the House by storm again. 

As Opposition members raised slogans and ruckus, Kurien said, “What can I do except adjourning. Both sides are indisciplined. The House is adourned till tomorrow (15 December) 11 am.”

No allegation against member: Kurien

​

Soon after Rajya Sabha passed the amended The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill (2014) and Kurien congratulated the members over a productive day, Anand Sharma raised the issue of Rijiju and his alleged involvement in the Rs 450-crore scam. Kurien tried to maintain calm in the House by saying, “Allegation without informing the Chair cannot be allowed.”

“What do I do with this Appropriation Bill?” asks Kurien. 

Congress's Anand Sharma raises issue of Kiren Rijiju's alleged involvement in corruption related to Arunachal Hydro Project in Rajya Sabha

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

Spoke too soon?

Soon after Kurien congratulates members of Upper House for passing the amended Disabilities Bill, Rajya Sabha erupts in ruckus as senior Congress leader Anand Sharma questions Kiren Rijiju’s involvement over the hydro project scam in Arunachal Pradesh.

​The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill (2014) as amended passed in Rajya Sabha

The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill (2014) as amended passed in Rajya Sabha #WinterSession

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

Rajya Sabha debates Disabilities Bill

CPM General Secretary Sitaram Yechury questions clauses mentioned in the Bill. “What is a mental disability? Who is the competent authority to judge?”

Rajya Sabha resumes clause by clause consideration of Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill.

— PRS Legislative (@PRSLegislative) December 14, 2016

Rajya Sabha resumes clause by clause consideration of Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill.

— PRS Legislative (@PRSLegislative) December 14, 2016

Lok Sabha Speaker slams Opposition: ‘You can’t have it both ways’

A united Opposition, during a press conference, alleged that the ruling BJP government is scheming and is not allowing Parliament to function. After Rahul Gandhi’s claims that he has information about corrupt practices that the prime minister is “personally” involved in, senior Opposition leaders slammed the BJP government for not allowing debate in the Lower House over issues that are important for the nation, like demonetisation. 

Interestingly, Lok Sabha Speaker Sumitra Mahajan lambasted the Opposition and said that “you cannot have it both ways.” Mahajan slammed the MPs, who disrupted the Parliament, and said, “Both things cannot happen at the same time. You (Opposition) protest in well and also ask for discussion.”

Both things cannot happen at the same time that you (Opp) protest in well and also ask for discussion: Sumitra Mahajan, LS Speaker pic.twitter.com/ECNwqLJNYS

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

BJP demands apology from Rahul Gandhi

Under desperation, R Gandhi's making such false charges as under his nose in AICC headquarters this scam came up;has to apologise: A Kumar pic.twitter.com/CbKxr7WbCi

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

“Why is Rahul Gandhi not revealing these earth-shattering info?” asks BJP

Minister for Parliamentary Affairs Ananth Kumar said that if Rahul Gandhi had any information, he could have revealed them twenty days ago, ““but till today he wasn’t ready to make any earth-shattering revelations.” 

BJP was reacting to Congress vice-president’s claim that he has information of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s alleged involvement in “personal corruption.” Rahul was speaking a joint press briefing of the Opposition after the Lok Sabha was adjourned for the day amid din created by Opposition. 

If R Gandhi had info,he could have revealed it 20 days ago, bt till today he wasn't ready to make any earth-shattering revelations-A Kumar pic.twitter.com/1i6caf1WZb

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

If R Gandhi had info,he could have revealed it 20 days ago, bt till today he wasn't ready to make any earth-shattering revelations-A Kumar pic.twitter.com/1i6caf1WZb

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

Allegations levelled against PM Modi by Cong VP is baseless. Rahul Gandhi ji has lost patience: Union Minister Ananth Kumar pic.twitter.com/Mr373OQ8R9

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

From day 1 we've been saying that we're ready for debate but unfortunate that Opposition is not allowing the House to function: Ananth Kumar

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

BJP denied allegations made by Rahul Gandhi 

Parliamentary Affairs Minister Anant Kumar denied the allegations made by Rahul Gandhi. He said it is the Congress party which has been disrupting proceedings in Parliament and added that the BJP is ready for a debate on demonetisation.

Demonetisation leading country towards national disaster: AK Antony

Former Defence Minister A K Antony said demonetisation would lead the country toward a national disaster and that Prime Minister Narendra Modi does not deserve a pardon. He was addressing the leaders and workers of the party at Jantar Mantar who are protesting the alleged bias against the co-operative banking sector post demonetisation.

“India as a whole is moving toward a national disaster due to the decision taken by Narendra Modi. This has given a chance to black money holders to convert it into white. Modi doesn’t deserve forgiveness,” Antony said. He also accused the Centre of trying to strangulate the co-operative and the agriculture sectors in the state.

With inputs from PTI

Watch: I have info of personal corruption of PM Modi, about which he is not being allowed to speak in Lok Sabha, says Rahul Gandhi

#WATCH Rahul Gandhi says he has info of personal corruption of PM Modi, about which he is not being allowed to speak in Lok Sabha pic.twitter.com/5h7NDjOmJk

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

Opposition puts onus on Modi govt over Parliament washout

“This is the first time that the government is scheming to make sure Parliament does not function. It usually is the job of Opposition to stand up and protest. However, this government is doing a pretty job of that and making sure that Parliament does not work and no one questions the ruling party’s decision. Demonetisation has hurt a lot of people, but Modi government’s arrogance is not allowing us to debate it in the House,” a TMC member said.

Delhi: Rahul Gandhi reaches Jantar Mantar to join United Democratic Front's (Kerala) protest over #DeMonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

If they muzzle me, we will hit the streets: Rahul Gandhi

Rahul Gandhi reiterates that he has “personal” information on Modi and has proof of corruption against the prime minister. 

Allow opposition to speak in the house.PM owes country an explanation, cannot keep running away to pop concerts&public meetings-Rahul Gandhi pic.twitter.com/b9c2Dcx4ON

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

I have information on Modi that will blow his balloon: Rahul Gandhi

“Prime Minister Narendra Modi is very scared because I have personal information on the prime minister. We have told the Speaker that please let us speak in the Parliament and it is our political right to speak in Parliament. But this government is opposing. Members of ruling government is up in arms and they are not letting the Opposition speak,” Rahul Gandhi address joint press conference.

I have some personal information about Modi, I am not being allowed to speak: Rahul Gandhi

Pichle ek mahine se poora opposition Lok Sabha mein charcha karni chahti hai. PM aur sarkar nahi chahte: Rahul Gandhi #DeMonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

PM is afraid that if he lets me speak then his balloon will burst: Rahul Gandhi #DeMonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

I have some personal information on PM Modi, which is what I want to speak on in Lok Sabha, but I am not being allowed to speak:Rahul Gandhi

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

Pradhanmantri ji ke baare mein bhrashtachar ka kuch personal info hai hamaare paas, jo vo hume sadan mein rakhne nahi de rahe:Rahul Gandhi

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

Joint media briefing of Opposition begins 

Joint media briefing of Opposition parties begins, Rahul Gandhi present #wintersession pic.twitter.com/LrchGGUwWG

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

‘Modi sarkaar hosh mein aao’: Lok Sabha adjourned for the day

Members in Lok Sabha shouted slogans against the BJP government and raised the issue of corruption allegations against Kiren Rijiju. BJP members slammed the Congress and said that party should first answer about their involvement in AgustaWestland scam.

Amid loud noise and sloganeering, Lok Sabha Speaker Sumitra Mahajan adjourned the Lower House for the day. It’s important to remember that just two more days are left for the Winter Session to wrap up and even though Rajya Sabha’s proceedings have been successful today, Lok Sabha witnessed the same scene with members shouting slogans and not letting the House function.

Lok Sabha adjourned till tomorrow, after continued uproar over #DeMonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

Opposition raises "Modi sarkar hosh me aao" slogans in Lok Sabha #DeMonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

It’s a sad day, Kharge is challenging the Speaker: Ananth Kumar

Chairman describes situation in Rajya Sabha as..... pic.twitter.com/ji7NoLwupy

— PRS Legislative (@PRSLegislative) December 14, 2016

Rajya Sabha adjourned till 2 pm

Rajya Sabha adjourned till 2 pm

— PRS Legislative (@PRSLegislative) December 14, 2016

Some MPs want to finish the clause by clause consideration of the Bill. Chairman insists that Q. hr be allowed to function as sched. pic.twitter.com/F3osJS7Uhq

— PRS Legislative (@PRSLegislative) December 14, 2016

Consideration on disability act postponed till 2 pm

Rajya Sabha to continue clause by clause consideration of the rights of persons with disabilities at 2 o clock after Q.hr

— PRS Legislative (@PRSLegislative) December 14, 2016

Rajya Sabha takes up clause by clause consideration of Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill 

RS taking up clause by clause consideration of Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill https://t.co/a52KyWxRkQ pic.twitter.com/meEWq1q4LN

— PRS Legislative (@PRSLegislative) December 14, 2016

Comparison of key provisions in the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Bill w/ official amendments & SC recos https://t.co/a52KyWxRkQ

— PRS Legislative (@PRSLegislative) December 14, 2016

Comparison of the Right of Persons with Disabilities Bill, 2014 and new amendments

Comparison of the Right of Persons with Disabilities Bill, 2014 and new amendments circulated. https://t.co/a52KyWxRkQ

— PRS Legislative (@PRSLegislative) December 14, 2016

Some amendments to The Right of Persons with Disabilities Bill, 2014 were circulated on Dec 1:You can find them here https://t.co/y4k4DjemNF

— PRS Legislative (@PRSLegislative) December 14, 2016

Rajya Sabha MPs urge that the Right of Persons with Disabilities Bill, 2014 be taken up immediately. https://t.co/pGIGyuvWI8

— PRS Legislative (@PRSLegislative) December 14, 2016

Rajya Sabha takes up Right of Persons with Disabilities Bill, 2014

Rajya Sabha taking up the Right of Persons with Disabilities Bill, 2014 for consideration and passage https://t.co/pGIGyuvWI8

— PRS Legislative (@PRSLegislative) December 14, 2016

Govt shares concern,its a serious crisis moment,some anticipated action was taken in advance- FM Arun Jaitley in RS on #CycloneVardah

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

Chidambaram tells BJP government to do more in Tamil Nadu

Former finance minister P Chidambaram tells the government in Centre, “Take my advice and make sure ATMs in Tamil Nadu are working fine. The government at the Centre has done good work but more needs to be done.”

Responding to it in Rajya Sabha, Arun Jaitley said, “We will do everything possible.”

Rajya Sabha, surprisingly, is showing a lot of maturity and has remained not adjourned

D Raja of CPM addresses Rajya Sabha over Cyclone Vardah. DMK members urge Centre to donate funds. P Chidambaram starts addressing Rajya Sabha.

Kiren Rijiju addresses Rajya Sabha

Minister of State for Home Kiren Rijiju gets up to introduce the Disability Bill, when Opposition members, including Ghulam Nabi Azad, Naresh Sharma and Mayawati, stood up and asked deputy chairman PJ Kurien to pass the bill rightaway. 

“Resume your seats, please. There is a procedure here. I am very happy that senior members want to pass this Bill. This bill (disability) is listed for 2 pm. If there is absolute consensus among the members to pass it during the Question Hour, then I have no issue. But there has to be a discussion. What do you want to do, now tell me?” asks Kurien.

Kiren Rijiju addresses Rajya Sabha

Minister of State for Home Kiren Rijiju gets up to introduce the Disability Bill, when Opposition members, including Ghulam Nabi Azad, Naresh Sharma and Mayawati, stood up and asked deputy chairman PJ Kurien to pass the bill rightaway. 

“Resume your seats, please. There is a procedure here. I am very happy that senior members want to pass this Bill. This bill (disability) is listed for 2 pm. If there is absolute consensus among the members to pass it during the Question Hour, then I have no issue. But there has to be a discussion. What do you want to do, now tell me?” asks Kurien.

Lok Sabha gets adjourned within 5 minutes

In presence of Prime MInister Narendra Modi, the Opposition members started creating ruckus right at the start of the House. 

While Speaker Sumitra Mahajan tried to maintain peace and quiet in the House, members of Parliament did not pay any heed to any of her words. The Lok Sabha has been adjourned till 12 pm.

Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha begin amid din

With two days of  the WinterSession left, legislative business in both houses remain pending

With two days of the #WinterSession left, legislative business in both houses remain pending. Scheduled LOB: 14.12.16 pic.twitter.com/pnnmMZpjFm

— PRS Legislative (@PRSLegislative) December 14, 2016

Anand Sharma gives notice for discussion on Rijiju’s alleged involvement

Congress is going to raise the issue of corruption charges against Kiren Rijiju. Rajya Sabha member and senior Congress leader, Anand Sharma has given notice under Rule 267 in Rajya Sabha for discussion on corruption charges against Rijiju. 

Congress to raise Kiren Rijiju's alleged involvement in Arunachal hydro scam issue in Rajya Sabha.

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

Anand Sharma gives notice under rule 267 in Rajya Sabha for discussion on Kiren Rijiju's alleged involvement in Arunachal hydro scam issue

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

BJP calls corruption charges against Rijiju as useless

Fijool ka mudda hai-Parl.Affairs Min. Ananth Kumar on Opp to raise Kiren Rijiju's alleged involvement in Arunachal hydro scam issue in LS&RS

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

Modi chairs meeting with top ministers

#FLASH PM Modi chairs meeting with top ministers in his chamber in Parliament. FM Jaitley, Ananth Kumar, Manohar Parrikar present in meet

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

Opposition parties meet to discuss strategy

Delhi: Opposition parties meeting underway in Parliament. pic.twitter.com/nWCxgapNq8

— ANI (@ANI) December 14, 2016

PM Modi likely to attend remaining three sittings of Parliament

According to an NDTV  report Information and Broadcasting Minister Venkaiah Naidu said that Prime Minister Modi will be present in Parliament for the three remaining days of the Session and can participate in proceedings for either of the House depending on the need.

“Prime Minister Narendra Modi will hold a meeting with key ministers before Parliament convenes on Wednesday morning to decide their strategy,” the report said.

BJP-Congress to debate on demonetisation

As the Parliament Winter session reconvenes after a four-day break, it looks like the Opposition may finally get the debate on demonetisation it has been asking for. With just three sittings left for the Winter session, the deadlock is likely to end, reports said. However, the remaining sittings are not likely to be all business as issues like SP Tyagi’s arrest in AugustaWestland VIP chopper scam and alleged corruption charges against Kiren Rijiju in Arunachal Hydro Power project may create an uproar in both the houses.

14 December: Winter Session Updates begin here

Rajya Sabha adjourned till 14 December

On Friday as the count of members in the Upper House remained 21 despite calls from the Deputy Chairman PJ Kurien, the house was adjourned till Monday. The benches remained empty while BJP and Congress leaders sparred with each other blaming each other for the non-functioning government. 

Rajya Sabha adjourned till December 14 #wintersession pic.twitter.com/43YR4KPvdd

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

Mamata and Manohar spar with each other

Outside the Parliament West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee said, “Govt not allowing the opposition to discuss Demonitisation in Lok Sabha.” She added, “On issue of demonetisation ,TMC and Congress are fighting together.”

Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar responded to Banerjee saying, “Pained.There’s process of raising issues,no prob with it.Calling it coup,to say Army ws collecting toll nt right.”

Pained.There's process of raising issues,no prob with it.Calling it coup,to say Army ws collecting toll nt right-Parrikar on letter to WB CM pic.twitter.com/GyTbQZKKUa

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

BJP blames Congress for no argument in the Rajya Sabha

Logjam continues in the Rajya Sabha on the 15th day of the Winter session of the Parliament. BJP and Congress leaders take digs at each other. Leader of the Opposition Ghulam Nabi Azad said, “The government is not functioning very well.”

Opposition is running away from discussion as they don't have any logic. They must apologise: Parliamentary Affairs Minister Ananth Kumar

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

Nationally bypolls mein mandate mil gaya, Internationally TIME magazine ka result aa gaya. Aur kaunsa mandate chahiye?: Venkaiah Naidu

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

Venkaiah Naidu: What is a foolish move? Action against black money hoarders? 

BJP and Congress continue to spar over stalling Parliament. Interestingly, prominent leaders are speaking more outside Parliament than inside. 

Senior BJP leader Venkaiah Naidu slammed Congress and said what is this party against? “Are they saying it is a foolish decision to act against black money hoarder?” 

Praising the demonetisation move, Naidu referred to the prime minister’s move as a historic one and said, “We have a few days left for Parliament to function. We have an important bill to consider and pass – mental health bill.”

Lakhs of people committed suicide due to distress under your(Congress) regime.Who are you preaching?: Venkaiah Naidu pic.twitter.com/WK7DJhVOyt

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

Watch: Rahul Gandhi hits out at govt

If they allow me to speak in parliament you'll see what an earthquake is going to come: Rahul Gandhi on #notesban #WinterSession @OfficeOfRG pic.twitter.com/AbOh1RJ0SS

— NDTV (@ndtv) December 9, 2016

Just before Lok Sabha was adjourned for the day

Parliament security breach matter: Motion adopted in Lok Sabha to suspend AAP MP Bhagwant Mann for remaining days of #wintersession

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

Lok Sabha tries just about to stay afloat amid din; Adjourned till 14 December

It’s hard to decide at this point who is trying to stall Parliament. During zero hour in Lok Sabha, MPs in Lok Sabha kept raising ruckus while Speaker Sumitra Mahajan tries her best to keep the House in session. 

Keep in mind that Vietnamese Parliamentarians are in both the Houses to witness this scene.

Despite President Pranab Mukherjee’s appeal on Thursday, relentless MPs continue stalling Parliament

Din continues in both Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha. “House wants the Question Hour or not?” asks Hamid Ansari. MPs reply in unison: “NO”

“Nothing can be done in this noise,” says Ansari.

Rahul Gandhi says

Since a month we've been trying debate on #DeMonetisation, hum chahte hain doodh ka doodh paani ka paani hojaye: Congress VP Rahul Gandhi pic.twitter.com/HvPygjeNyz

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

PM poore desh mein bhashan de rahe hain magar Lok Sabha mein aane se darrte hain. Itni ghabrahat kyun?: Rahul Gandhi pic.twitter.com/sjJrTOcjU0

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

“Govt running from debate, if they allow me to speak then you will see what an earthquake will come,” says Rahul Gandhi.

Govt running from debate,if they allow me to speak then you will see what an earthquake will come: Rahul Gandhi #DeMonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

Rajya Sabha adjourned till 12 noon as opposition raises "Kisan virodhi, gareeb virodhi, ye sarkar nahi chalegi" pic.twitter.com/DucWDMBlqs

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

Opposition members storm Rajya Sabha Well

Kisaani virodhi ye sarkaar, nahi chalegi nahi chalegi

TMC’s Sukhendu Shekar Roy demands obit reference for those who died while standing in ATM queues

All India Trinamool Congress member, Roy said that when all these things are being discussed in Rajya Sabha, obituary references must be made for all those who died while standing in ATM queues.

Smriti Irani interrupts: Rather than have a debate, can we transact some business?

Ram Vilas Paswan replies to Yechury’s point – debate on wheat production

Paswan says that the minute there is a slight increase in the prices of things, Opposition creates a ruckus. Paswan also ignored calls of Opposition members saying the reason is demonetisation. 

Sharad Yadav: The government should not ignore this, it is a matte of farmers. 

Jairam Ramesh: Reduction of import duty for wheat sales is ridiculous. It is a slap on the face of the farmer of the country. 

Govt needs to rethink on #DeMonetisation or farmers will have to bear huge losses, they'll be ruined: Mayawati in RS

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

Union Min of Food & Public Distribution Ram Vilas Paswan clarifies in RS, "we have enough food grain"

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

Parliamentarians from Vietnam to see how Indian Parliament works 

​As if the logjam in Parliament — for which President Pranab Mukherjee admonished both Houses — was not embarrassing enough for the country, there is now a delegation of parliamentarians from Vietnam who are going to witness what happens in an Indian Parliament.

BJP MPs create ruckus when Yechury speaks

Congress’ Anand Sharma raises objection to BJP MPs creating ruckus when CPM General Secretary Sitaram Yechury was speaking in Rajya Sabha. 

Deputy Chairman PJ Kurien, in a strong rebuttal, told Anand Sharma that he is completely right and when Chair allows someone to speak, he/she should not be heckled and be allowed to speak, but Kurien also said, “your party members are also making the ruckus.”

They are ruining the Indian 'annadata' (farmers): Sitaram Yechury in RS #DeMonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

Aapko sweekar karna padega ke ye ek desh drohi nirnay hai : Sitaram Yechury in RS #DeMonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

Rahul Gandhi might speak in Lok Sabha

Sources said that the Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi might speak on demonetisation today in Lok Sabha. 

But we will have to wait for that as the strings of adjournments have already begun, starting with Lok Sabha. Rajya Sabha is still progressing in a calm manner. 

Lok Sabha adjourned till 11.30 am after uproar over #DeMonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

Lok Sabha: Opposition creates ruckus right at the start

“I cannot hear anyone. Please keep quiet. House stands adjourned to meet again at 11.30,” Speaker Sumitra Mahajan.

It’s Day 15 of Parliament

Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha will soon begin. For the past 15 sittings, Parliament’s Winter Session has been a washout with the Opposition stalling proceedings over the issue of demonetisation. 

Opposition leaders on Friday are going to meet Lok Sabha Speaker Sumitra Mahajan shortly. 

Opposition leaders to meet Lok Sabha Speaker shortly #wintersession

— ANI (@ANI) December 9, 2016

Lok Sabha passes govt’s demand for supplementary grants amid din

The Lok Sabha on Thursday passed amid din the Second Supplementary Demands for Grants (General) for 2016-17 and Demands for Excess Grants (General) for 2013-14.

With inputs from IANS

Take stern action against those playing mischief with I-T schemes: BJP MP

Kirit Somaiya said the government has taken decisions like demonetisation and Income Declaration Scheme to curb black money but some people are doing  mischief.

Somaiya sought  stern action against such people, citing instances of people claiming to have huge amounts of money to declare under a recent scheme even though they did not have it.

Ashamed and disgusted the way some parliamentarians are behaving: Babul Supriyo

BJP MP and Union Minister of State for Heavy Industries & Public Enterprises Babul Supriyo said that being a first time parliamentarian, he was shocked and ashamed to go to the parliament only to leave it within half and hour.

He also took to to twitter and named some parliamentarians from the Opposition accusing them of using ‘dramatic & theatrical’ ways to disrupt the parliament.

Disgusted&Ashamed by the 'dramatic & theatrical' way Susmita Dev, Gourav Gagoi(Congress), Arpita Ghosh(Trinamool) disrupted Lok Sabha

— Babul Supriyo (@SuPriyoBabul) December 8, 2016

I wud love 2 knw if any1 of these 3 MPs I mentioned in my previous tweet, made any contribution 2 the Parliamentary system in the last 2+yrs

— Babul Supriyo (@SuPriyoBabul) December 8, 2016

BJP dares Rahul Gandhi to speak on note ban in Parliament

Accusing Rahul Gandhi of levelling baseless allegations against the government to grab headlines, BJP on Thursday dared him to speak on demonetisation in Parliament.

Congress ran way from discussion in Parliament when it was in power and it is doing the same now when it is in the opposition, BJP National Secretary Shrikant Sharma alleged.

“His (Rahul’s) charges against the Modi government are borne out of his incompetence and arrogance. He is competing with Arvind Kejriwal in TRP politics by levelling baseless charges on almost daily basis. He is doing so merely for headlines. He should instead speak in Parliament not outside,” Sharma said.

Bhagwant Mann suspended from the Lok Sabha for the rest of the session

According to Times Now, the parliamentary panel has found Mann guilty of security breach after he filmed a video entering Parliament by crossing several security layers and posted it on social media.

‘Congress-led Opposition observing Black Money Support Day’

Hitting out at the Congress-led Opposition for observing a ‘Black Day’ against demonetisation decision, government on Thursday said they are actually observing a “Black Money Support Day”.

Information and Broadcasting Minister Venakaiah Naidu also termed the ‘dharna’ by opposition leaders near the Gandhi statue in Parliament premises as a big ’tamasha’ and an insult to the Father of the Nation. “Our opponents particularly the Congress I am told are observing a Black Day. I say what they are observing is a ‘Black Money Support Day’,” Naidu said.

Was Winter Session entirely wasted?

The Winter Session of Parliament began on 16 November. On 8 December, both the Houses — Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha — met for the 14th day but within minutes of commencing, both the Houses were adjourned. The deadlock over demonetisation has led to wastage of the Winter Session so far and considering that just one more week is left for the session to wrap up, there is little hope that the Houses will be able to pass, introduce or even debate the Bills that have been listed for consideration.

Has the Winter Session turned out to be a complete waste of time? Read the full article here .

Lok Sabha adjourned till 11 am on Friday

’Narendra Modi bhag gaya!’ and ‘Mann Ki Baat band karo!’ the new slogans being raised in Lok Sabha

PM has said that things will be normal by Dec 30: Arun Jaitley speaks in Lok Sabha amidst uproar pic.twitter.com/SZ55f7llpZ

— News18 (@CNNnews18) December 8, 2016

Govt working to reduce inconvenience: Jaitley in LS

“I want to specify that the prime minister has said that we will make efforts to minimise the difficulties faced by the people till 30 December. There is an effort to reduce inconvenience for the people,” Finance Minister Arun Jaitley said in the Lok Sabha.

’Jhoote sapne band karo’ and ‘desh ko lootna band karo’ slogans heard in Lok Sabha

President condemns Parliament logjam

President Pranab Mukherjee has accused the Opposition of “gagging majority” in both Houses of Parliament. “Debate, dissension and decision are necessary,” Times Now quoted the President as saying. “The Parliament must not be disrupted…this is unacceptable.”

Decibel levels rise as Finance Minister Arun Jaitley speaks in Lok Sabha

People only supporting demonetisation to see corruptions levels go down: TDP in Lok Sabha

“Most people only supported this move because they wanted corruption levels to come down,” Jayadev Galla of the TDP said in the Lok Sabha, adding that the people will be angry and disappointed if corruption levels do not come down.

Demonetisation created situation similar to war against financial structure of India: BJD in LS

“Naveen Patnaik has supported demonetisation and the fight against black money. But there is a war-like situation in the country. It is a war on the financial structure of our country,” Rabindra Kumar Jena of the BJD said in the Lok Sabha.

“Growth is there in our country but it is not job-led growth,” he said.

Parliament is liable to people. That was not taken into account. One man show where he has cause disaster to the country: Mamata Bannerjee pic.twitter.com/CNfFhbZBu7

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

Rajya Sabha adjourned till 11 am on Friday

Our govt moving towards digital economy: BJP in Lok Sabha

“The curse of black money is one given by 60 years of rule before the Modi government. Our government is not only fighting against black money but also moving towards a digital and cashless economy,” BJP’s Kirit Somaiya said in the Lok Sabha.

“When my Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s name comes along with two or three other top leaders in a magazine like TIME, I feel proud,” he said.

“We should come up with incentives for people so that they move towards a cashless economy,” Somaiya said.

Uproar over demonetisation erupts in Lok Sabha

Parliament proceedings resume

Lok Sabha adjourned till 2 pm

“Some mischievous persons are trying to spread wrong rumours about Modiji’s demonetisation decision and the undisclosed income declaration scheme,” said BJP MP Kirit Somaiya in the Lok Sabha.

My speech is ready: Rahul Gandhi

Mai bolna chah raha hoon, mera bhaashan tayaar hai. BJP ke log aajayein, shuru karein...sab pata lag jayga: Rahul Gandhi pic.twitter.com/PypNeoCeT8

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

Mai kehta hoon aap (PM Modi) andar aaiyey Lok Sabha mein, humein bolne dijiye, phir Lok Sabha mein reply karna: Rahul Gandhi,Congress VP pic.twitter.com/2uuuecd6We

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

‘We want Modi!’ slogans heard in Lok Sabha

Uproar erupts yet again in Lok Sabha

It has almost become like Opposition’s everyday habit to shout and protest in the Lok Sabha.

Advaniji jaise senior vyakti ab roz aa kar nazara dekh rahe hain; baat toh sahi hai Parl chalna chahiye,prayas kar rahe hain-Sumitra Mahajan pic.twitter.com/RhWdIACvVi

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

Rajya Sabha adjourned till 2 pm

Rajya Sabha session resumes

But the Opposition members have started shouting again, as usual.

Lok Sabha adjourned till 12 pm

This entire month has been a black month for 90 percent of the people: Mayawati

Sahi mayane mei 90% janta ke liye kala din Nov 8 se hi shuru ho gaya tha; Unke liye ek poora mahina kala din ke roop mei guzra hai: Mayawati pic.twitter.com/q6HRP0MTca

— ANI UP/Uttarakhand (@ANINewsUP) December 8, 2016

Vipaksh ka koi vyaktigat swarth nahi hai, Desh ke 90% janta ke hit ko dhyan mei rakh kar kala diwas manaya gaya hai: BSP Chief Mayawati pic.twitter.com/Y926wpBOQB

— ANI UP/Uttarakhand (@ANINewsUP) December 8, 2016

Please don’t disrupt the House: LS Speaker tells Oppn

“If you want to debate, you can do that. But please do not disrupt the House,” Lok Sabha Speaker Sumitra Mahajan told the shouting Opposition members in the House.

’Modi sarkar hai hai!" slogans heard in Lok Sabha

You have to wonder about whether Opposition MPs think of new slogans to shout in the Parliament everyday or whether everything is spontaneous.

Decibel levels rising in Lok Sabha

Opposition members have now started shouting with more intensity in the Lok Sabha, making proceedings look like a joke.

Rajya Sabha adjourned till 12 pm

Absolute chaos in Rajya Sabha

It seems there is some sort of shouting match between the Opposition and the government now. It truly is surprising to see almost every member of the Rajya Sabha shout and scream.

It is a matter of shame that govt refuses to pay tributes to people killed due to demonetisation: Congress in RS

“We have been saying for a long time that over 100 people have died because of demonetisation,” said Ghulam Nabi Azad in Rajya Sabha. “But the government refused to pay tribute to the deceased,” he added.

He also said that by protesting in front of the Gandhi statue, the Opposition was the one which paid tributes to the deceased.

“It is a matter of shame that the government refused to pay tributes to the martyrs,” Azad thundered, provoking the ruling party ministers and MPs, who began shouting as if Azad had just thrown something at them.

“There is a limit even to shamelessness,” Azad said.

’Advaniji ne kya kaha?’ slogan heard in Rajya Sabha

An MP from the Opposition parties shouted “Advaniji ne kya kaha?” in the Rajya Sabha. It is interesting to note that Advani had blamed both the government and the Opposition for the stalement in Parliament.

For 2 wks you didn't allow debate to take place in Parl, now you're staging dharna in front of statue that’s big tamasha done by Cong: Naidu pic.twitter.com/Zee6KA8KlO

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

Ruling party MPs create uproar in Rajya Sabha

Strangely enough, now it is the ruling party MPs who are shouting slogans in the House after Venkaiah Naidu alleged that the Opposition was not allowing the government to speak.

Argument over demonetisation erupts in Rajya Sabha

“Let there be debate,” said Venkaiah Naidu as another MP alleged that over 100 people had died due to demonetisation.

And just like that, Rajya Sabha proceedings descended into chaos.

Venkaiah Naidu lashes out at Rahul Gandhi

“Gandhiji gave call for Satyagrah to see that victory of truth prevails; What are so-called namesake Gandhis doing? Observing protest,” ANI quoted Naidu as saying.

By simply posing for photo op in front of Gandhiji, you (Opposition) can't claim legacy of Mahatma Gandhi;You're insulting his memory: Naidu pic.twitter.com/VK3tMi5nmu

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

Rajya Sabha proceedings going smoothly for now

Rajya Sabha is actually functioning smoothly for a change. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for Lok Sabha where Opposition members have resorted to their usual shouting and protesting.

Uproar erupts in Lok Sabha

Demonetisation has been a major failure: Sitaram Yechury

On his Facebook page, CPM General Secretary Sitaram Yechury said: 

One month is a good time to take a stock of the crisis unleashed by Modi’s demonetisation announcement.

He had claimed four aims during his announcement — corruption, terrorism, fake currency and black money. Each of these aims has proven to be wrong, both factually and by empirical evidence on ground.

He has now shifted the goalpost to digital payment, a word missing in his TV speech on 8 November, which makes no sense in a country like ours, unless the goal is to exclude the poor and the downtrodden from participating in India’s economy.

The economy has ground to a halt in the last month, and not one section of the society has been left untouched from the turmoil, hardship and pain caused by the Tughlaqi firman. The poor, whom Modi claims to speak for, have been the worst sufferers as rich black money holders have been given another opportunity to convert their ill-gotten wealth to white by paying some additional tax.

Watch: Rahul Gandhi says demonetisation was a foolish move

#WATCH: Congress VP Rahul Gandhi says, PM Narendra Modi's so-called bold decision (#DeMonetisation) was a "foolish" decision. pic.twitter.com/rO1BxNsW3p

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

One month since demonetisation, Opposition observes Black Day

8 November was when Prime Minister Narendra Modi announced the scrapping of Rs 500 and Rs 1,000 notes. It’s been a month since then and the Opposition protests have gone on unabated – both in and outside Parliament. 

Today, Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi launched a full frontal attack on the prime minister and an united Opposition on Thursday observed Black Day to mark one month since the demonetisation scheme kicked in. 

Parliament begins at 11 am and today is Day 17 of Winter Session. 

Aaj 30 din ho gaye hain jabse #DeMonetisation decision liya gaya; Hum koi naare nahi rakhenge, black day banayenge, maun hoga: GN Azad, Cong pic.twitter.com/j5W4qTTxPZ

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

Delhi: Opposition leaders observing black day to mark one month of #demonetisation at Gandhi statue inside Parliament premises. pic.twitter.com/PQI20r1r5G

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

Rahul Gandhi says PayTm is actually Pay To Modi

​

Targetting the Prime Minister over the issue of note ban, Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi slammed the BJP government saying that the decision to scrap high denomination currency was the biggest mistake ever. “It was a bold decision – that’s what Modi ji says – but bold decisions are also foolish decisions. Demonetisation was a foolish decision. Our farmers, fishermen and the poor of the society are dying, our Prime Minister does not care for any of that. He (PM Modi) is laughing and having a nice time while the people of the country are suffering. The idea behind cashless economy is that a few people and corporates will get maximum benefits from these transactions. This has damaged the nation.”

When asked what does the Opposition want, Rahul said, “He should come and debate in Parliament and explain his decision,” he said. 

It has devastated poor, farmers,daily wage workers. We want to have a discussion. We want a vote, Govt doesn't: Rahul Gandhi #demonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

This is not a bold decision, it is a foolish decision which has been taken without any due consideration: Rahul Gandhi on #demonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

PM's narrative has changed; started by saying its against black money,thn terrorism,then counterfeit currency&later cashless economy-RGandhi

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

PM Modi is running away, if he comes to the House for debate, we won't let him run: Rahul Gandhi on #demonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

Lok Sabha mein agar mujhe bolne diya jaye toh main sab bata doonga ki Paytm kaise "PAY TO MODI" hota hai: Rahul Gandhi

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

He (PM Modi) is laughing, having a nice time while the people of the country are suffering: Rahul Gandhi #demonetisation pic.twitter.com/Llt0ZEsnwr

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

The idea behind cashless economy is that a few ppl must get maximum benefits from these transactions, this has damaged the nation: RGandhi

— ANI (@ANI) December 8, 2016

Rajya Sabha adjourned till 11 am on Thursday

Opposition members storm Well of Rajya Sabha

Govt should quit: Congress in RS

Congress leader Pramod Tiwari said that demonetisation violated provisions in the COnstitution and said that the entire government and council of ministers should quit.

Jaitley asks Oppn in RS to avoid imposing ‘unreasonable and impossible conditions for a debate’

“We’ve gone through this exercise of having a major debate which is incomplete. We have spent seven hours on the debate under rule 167,” said Finance Minister Arun Jaitley in Rajya Sabha.

“It’s obviously an important issue. The questions have to be answered,” he said. “The government and the council of ministers fucntions on a collective responsibility. There is no such principle that a specific person has to answer.”

“In this case, we’ve repeatedly said that the prime minister is going to participate in the debate,” Jaitley said.

“What is the stage we are in? Halfway through the debate, you interrupted the debate and are now raising concerns which have never been raised in the House,” he told the Opposition.

“In the 2G debates, we have insisted that the prime minister participates in this discussions but there is no such practice in this House that the prime minister must be here to listen to each and every member,” Jaitley said.

“Let the Opposition not impose unreasonable and impossible conditions for a debate,” he added.

“Respect the sentiments of the House,” Sitaram Yechury said in response.

Demonetisation affecting foreigners in India: Congress in Rajya Sabha

“The government has collective responsibility but the prime minister is the first among the equals,” said Congress leader Anand Sharma in Rajya Sabha.

“Demonetisation created a situation that 86 percent of the currency was invalidated. Now, after one month, tens of millions of Indians are standing in queues…It is wrong to give an impression that the Opposition is opposing the prime minister’s crusade against black money,” Sharma said.

“Today, the situation is that the withdrawals of the foreigners who come to India are being rationed,” he said. “This has globally affected India’s image,” he added.

“He (the prime minister) must answer our questions. India’s image has been damaged globally,” he said.

Presence of PM in Rajya Sabha demanded again

“Nobody is challenging demonetisation. We are talking about the fallout of demonetisation,” said K Keshava Rao, TRS MP, in the Rajya Sabha.

“As far as monetary issues are concerned, the finance minister should answer. But who will answer the other things?” Rao said. “Whom should we address for the issues we want to talk about?” he added.

“The co-ordinator of the ministries is the prime minister…I want the Leader of the House to understand the spirit of the Constitution,” he said.

Issue of BJP leader caught with cash in Bengal raised in Rajya Sabha

“A BJP leader was caught in Bengal with cash in new notes and some weapons. Will your government investigate?” said an MP in the Rajya Sabha.

Lok Sabha adjourned till 11 am on Thursday

‘We want discussion with voting!’ slogans heard in the Lok Sabha

As soon as the Parliament proceedings resumed, Opposition members began shouting in both the Houses.

Lok Sabha adjourned till 2 pm

 JD(U) MP Harivansh laments about Parliament disruptions

“These photos on the walls of the Rajya Sabha, from where emanates the power of democracy, often haunt me. It has been particularly difficult these last few days to get past those photos.Till 1 December (15th day since the commencement of the Winter Session) no business has been allowed to occur in the House except on the first day when a good debate took place in the Rajya Sabha over demonetisation. Regular disruptions, chaos and high-pitched slogan shouting have resulted in complete pandemonium in the House. The continuous ruckus usually leads to the suspension of the House proceedings and, sadly, it has become a regular feature. I ask myself: is this the only alternative left to us to address the genuine grievances of the public, the states and the nation?”

Kya PM isliye maafi maange kyunki jo ghotalebaaz hain unka banta dhaar ho raha hai?: MA Naqvi on Oppn apology demand #DeMonetisation pic.twitter.com/S24eUqVEJn

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016

Lok Sabha is better than Rajya Sabha

​

Unrelenting Speaker Sumitra Mahajan continues to let MPs speak on different issues while a group of MPs continue to try to disrupt Lok Sabha. But since Winter Session has begun (16 November) members who are against the demonetisation drive have tried, and sometimes successfully, to stall Parliament. 

If one had to compare, Rajya Sabha gets adjourned way faster and sooner than the Lower House.

Opposing members continue raising ruckus

Rajya Sabha has been adjourned till 2 pm and the way it looks Lok Sabha will soon get adjourned. 

The interesting thing to note is that the opposing members and those raising slogans do not care for what subject is being discussed in the House. Slogans like “Modi sarkaar haye haye” and “Modi sarkaar jawab do” are being loudly raised in Lok Sabha.

Modi Sarkaar haye haye, yell opposing members in Lok Sabha

Lok Sabha Speaker Sumitra Mahajan asks members the reason for yelling. But no one responds.

Ruckus gets louder in Lok Sabha

Ruckus in Lok Sabha continues unabated

Rajya Sabha Chairman Hamid Ansari hopelessly looks around

Opposition members raise slogans and stall Rajya Sabha again. Debates not allowed and Chairman of Upper House Hamid Ansari quietly and hopelessly looks around. 

Rajya Sabha adjourned till 2 pm.

Rajya Sabha resumes and so do protests

Lok Sabha is adjourned till 12 pm

Lok Sabha adjourned till 12 noon #DeMonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016

BJP and Opposition debate over note ban

Opposition: Modiji says he wants the poor to build their own homes, but what about those homes which are being broken?

BJP:  They can approach the government. We promise action.

Someone has to take a step back: Shiv Sena

Someone has to step back at least for the country, be it Govt or opposition: Sanjay Raut, Shiv Sena on #DeMonetisation pic.twitter.com/nNj1bzB8zk

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016

Lok Sabha inching towards adjournment

Opposition members are protesting against the ruling government in the Lower House. Rajya Sabha has already been adjourned.

Rajya Sabha adjourned till noon

BJP MPs raise 'Himmat hai toh charcha karo' slogans in Rajya Sabha #DeMonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016

Everyone is speaking Rajya Sabha

While Mayawati attempts to speak in Upper House, protesting MPs kept raising slogans while deputy chairman PJ Kurien tried to soothe protesting members.

“Please stop shouting.” 

“Why Treasury bench is behaving this way?”

Jaitley blames Congress and Opposition for stalling Parliament

After Ghulam Nabi Azad raised the note ban issue again in Rajya Sabha, finance minister Arun Jaitley says that the debate had begun and was happening in the House. But it was the Opposition who interrupted the debate and for publicity has continued to not let Parliament function. 

We were ready for debate and still are. Opposition wanted PM to be present in the house so PM has been regularly present: Arun Jaitley in RS

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016

But it seems the opposition just wants to disrupt proceedings for one reason or the other: Arun Jaitley in RS #DeMonetisation pic.twitter.com/245Svy7aVq

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016

Ghulam Nabi Azad questions BJP’s silence on deaths due to demonetisation

Ruckus erupts in Rajya Sabha after Leader of House Ghulam Nabi Azad says, “It’s been a month now and 84 people have died.”

PJ Kurien tells members to calm down and sit down. Slogans like, “himmat hai toh charcha karo (Debate if you have courage)” were raised by the Opposition.

Its been a month now and 84 people have died: Ghulam Nabi Azad in Rajya Sabha #DeMonetisation pic.twitter.com/gf2dWUXKlq

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016

Govt took this decision without planning, who is responsible for so many deaths?: Ghulam Nabi Azad,Congress in RS #DeMonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016

Opposition wants discussion under Rule 184 in Lok Sabha. 

In Rajya Sabha, on problems faced by salaried employees and pensioners.

Opposition meeting ends,wants discussion under rule 184 in LS. In RS on problems faced by salaried employees & pensioners #DeMonetisation

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016

Both, the Opposition parties and the BJP Parliamentary Party, met before parliamentary proceedings began

PM ne kaha jaise matdaan ke samay desh mein EVM ke baare mein prachar hota hai waise hi cashless system ka prachar hona chahiye:Ananth Kumar

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016

Ek resolution pass kiya gaya ki jisme jis tarah se janta ne #demonetization ka samarthan kiya uska swagat kiya: Ananth Kumar

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016

Ek resolution pass kiya gaya ki jisme jis tarah se janta ne #demonetization ka samarthan kiya uska swagat kiya: Ananth Kumar

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016

Rajya Sabha pays tribute to Cho Ramaswamy

​

Rajya Sabha observes silence to mark the memory of Cho Ramaswamy

Meeting of opposition parties underway in Parliament 

Delhi: BJP Parliamentary party meeting underway #wintersession pic.twitter.com/DpPjsc3xQI

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016

Meeting of opposition parties underway in parliament #WinterSession pic.twitter.com/Na2mF9jeus

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016

Meeting of opposition parties underway in Parliament 

Delhi: BJP Parliamentary party meeting underway #wintersession pic.twitter.com/DpPjsc3xQI

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016

Meeting of opposition parties underway in parliament #WinterSession pic.twitter.com/Na2mF9jeus

— ANI (@ANI) December 7, 2016