It seems IS decision-makers see this reality and are turning to the fertile recruiting grounds in Turkey, as indicated by the surge in IS output on social media.
Judging from the Islamic State's (IS) losses of
territory and revenue in Iraq and Syria, IS is coming under more pressure by the day. If the losses continue at this pace, many observers think 2016 could well
be the final year of IS in these two countries.
It seems IS decision-makers see this reality and are turning to the fertile
recruiting grounds in Turkey, as indicated by the surge in IS
output on social media. It is obvious from its propaganda strategy that IS
first wants to conquer the cyberworld, and then — with the
virtual caliphate — it will set up there and capture hearts
and minds in Turkey.
An IS propaganda video professionally produced in Turkish
and released in November was viewed more than 100,000 times on social
media platforms such as YouTube, Facebook and others. Quoting
extensively from the Quran, it calls on IS sympathizers to migrate with their
families to Islamic countries such as Iraq and Syria. But in recent days there
has been a significant change in the themes of Turkish-language, pro-IS social
media and commentary sites. The Turkish versions now say, “You can serve
the Islamic State where you are.”
For example, under Twitter hashtags such as #IslamDevleti and #HilafetTR,
IS has been saying that the religion in Turkey today is not the Islam of
Mecca. It is instead “a democratic religion bereft of jihad as decided by
its parliament and approved by the USA. This religion cannot be called Islam.
We reject it.”
The comments now emphasize that the struggle with the
democratic order in Turkey has priority over migration.
Despite all countermeasures of the state, there has been a
substantial rise in the number of social media sites, accounts and
commentary blogs that demonize Turkey's secular education system,
reject democracy and the constitution, harshly criticize the
dominant traditional religious communities and their spiritual
narratives and thrash compulsory military service.
Reyhan Guner of Bilkent University, who researches
cybersecurity, confirmed a visible increase in the Turkish-language
content of IS cybermedia. She said this is easily measured. “For example, you
can notice two basic elements. The first is the sympathy IS has been
accumulating among anti-PKK [Kurdistan Workers Party] religious groups
in Turkey because of the battles between IS and PKK/PYD [Democratic Union
Party] Kurds. The second is the sympathy generated in religious-nationalist
circles for the armed struggle waged against global forces in Syria,” Guner
told Al-Monitor.
These two currents of sympathy have made IS a
center attraction in daily political debates in Turkey. Guner says IS has
been following a clever strategy in its Turkish-language output. “It is
interesting to note how IS focuses its Turkish propaganda on new adherents or
sympathizers of IS. There are scores of IS people, originating from
economically deprived parts of Turkey, posting photographs of luxury villas and
fancy cars they claim to own after joining IS because they have gotten their
hands on what they call ‘war booty.’ Through such messages, they want to
motivate their relatives, friends and others who are unhappy with their current
circumstances to join IS,” she said.
IS is thus exploiting not only the ideological but also
socio-economic fault lines of Turkey.
Guner notes that IS, in addition to its online propaganda
journals such as “Conquest of Konstantiniyye,” is using debate forums in
Turkish to enable easy access to comments and decrees from IS. In these
publications, profound ideological debates have overtaken the former
emphasis on execution visuals. For example, a blog run by Twitter account @Tevhidmedya calls for “Islamic resistance” because
all officials of Turkey's democratic political structure are “infidels” and
those who follow them will be the same.
Another interesting feature of extremist Salafi social media platforms that call for
jihad in Turkey is how content can be confusing when the same page
contains accolades about IS along with messages of praise for other
jihadi bodies. For example, after IS shot down a Russian Mi-25 assault
helicopter July 10 near Palmyra, one Twitter account lauded the
action as a military victory. But at the same time, it was also
praising the Eid al-Fitr celebrations of Jabhat al-Nusra, which is
actually combating IS. Another account presents reports from Amak news
agency that offer information about IS in Turkish, along with information
about Ahrar al-Sham, a key group among anti-IS moderate organizations in
Syria.
Here, Turkey must recognize a critical reality. When the
issue is jihadis in Syria and their military
accomplishments, Salafi sympathizers in Turkey do not distinguish
between IS and other armed Salafists. For Turkey, the line between IS and other
Salafi armed groups is becoming more blurred by the day. This could pave
the way for armed Salafists in Turkey to adopt IS ways.
The question one must ask here is, does Turkey have an
adequate strategy to cope with the increasing number of Turkish-language
messages of IS and other extremist Salafists? Does Ankara have a strategic
vision of how to battle Salafi currents in cyberspace? Guner believes
Turkish politicians and the public are not really aware of the potential
dangers of radicalization, terrorism and cyberterrorism prevailing in the
virtual world.
“Sadly, in Turkey the concept of cybersecurity is limited to
not using "12345" as your email password and not allowing
children to view IS execution videos. In our schools we have introduced the use
of tablets, but we don’t have a cybersecurity class to teach children the
dangers they may encounter on the internet. It is just a matter of time before
you find yourself in a debate forum of an illegal organization just by
clicking on an advertisement that appears on the same page with your
usual traditional news or comment site,” Guner said.
Guner worries that Ankara still doesn’t have a
comprehensive cybersecurity mindset, one that says leaders must protect
both government and personal internet users. She strongly recommends that
Turkey and other Muslim countries in the
region launch a diplomacy initiative to collectively
fight radicalization in cyberspace.
To sum up, while IS is losing territory, it is trying
to compensate by setting up its caliphate in cyberspace. One has to wonder
whether the next IS phase will be to join efforts with other ideologically
related bodies, courtesy of the capabilities offered online.
At this moment, we can only hope that there are some brains
in Ankara searching for ways to deal with IS cyberspace operations.