MFIs loaned $187m in 2015, but fell into consumptive lending trap
1. By Tawanda Musarurwa
HARARE – Zimbabwe’s
MicroFinance Institutions
(MFIs) may have largely
failed to improve the capaci-
ties of small businesses, with
a large portion of their loans
going towards consumption.
An MFI is an organisation
that offers financial services
to low income populations,
and although there is no pre-
requisite for these institu-
tions to focus on productive
sector funding, expectations
were that they would cater
to funding small-to-medium
enterprises.
Small businesses are a
sector that the larger local
banks have had a generally
low appetite for due to per-
ceived credit risk.
However, Reserve Bank of
Zimbabwe (RBZ) statistics
show that the MFI loans
distribution trends in the
country between 2013 and
2015 has been invariably
dominated by consumptive
lending.
2013 figures show that
MFIs extended loans total-
ing $164,2 million, of which
70,8 percent ($116 million)
went to consumption, while
the balance ($47,8 million or
29,1 percent) went towards
the productive sectors.
There was an improvement
in 2014 in respect of the
ratio, but the key trend
was unchanged as MFIs
loaned out a total of $156,
9 million, with consumption
absorbing 53,3 percent of
those loans ($83,5 million).
46,7 percent or $73,4 million
went to production.
And as at the end of last
year, MFIs had a total loan
book of $187,1 million and
only $85, 6 million, rep-
resenting 45,7 percent of
the total loan book, was
channeled to the productive
sectors, with the remaining
$101,5 million (54,2 percent)
being consumptive loans.
Analysts say that the liquid-
ity challenges characterising
the economy has compelled
MFIs to take a predatory
approach to lending at the
cost of broader economic
recovery.
Meanwhile, RBZ deputy gov-
ernor Dr Charity Dhliwayo
says the country now has
News Update as @ 1530 hours, Monday 23 May 2016
Feedback: bh24admin@zimpapers.co.zwEmail: bh24feedback@zimpapers.co.zw
MFIs loaned $187m in 2015, but fell into consumptive lending trap
Dr Charity Dhliwayo
2. four deposit-taking MFIs,
which has expanded the
range of services available to
low income earners and small
businesses.
“Following the promulga-
tion of the MicroFinance Act
(Chapter 24:29) in 2013, the
registration of deposit-taking
microfinance institutions has
broadened the product range
for the target clientele of low
income segments of the pop-
ulation. To date four micro-
finance banks have been
registered,” she said.
Dr Dhliwayo added that
SMEs’ deposits would be
treated as any other in case
of a bank failure.
“The RBZ intervenes in the
resolution (including exit) of
troubled banking institutions
to minimise loss to deposi-
tors. Where a bank is closed,
SMEs are treated in the same
manner as other creditors or
depositors.”
.●
2 news
Tobacco volumes, income rise from last year
BH24 Reporter
HARARE - Tobacco farmers
have received $221 mil-
lion after selling 80 million
kilogrammes of flue-cured
tobacco since the opening
of the marketing season on
March 30.
Statistics from the Tobacco
Industry and Marketing
Board (TIMB) shows that the
volumes and income from
the crop have increased 34
percent compared to the
same period last year.
TIMB statistics indicated
that a total of 58 million
kg of tobacco worth $166
million was sold during
the same period last year.
Prices for this season have
increased since the opening
of the season.
The average price of tobacco
for this season has declined
from $2,86 last year to
$2,76 on day 36. TIMB
statistics show that the
highest price at the auc-
tion remained at $4,99 per
kg while the crop at the
contract floors has fetched
a highest price of $6,25 per
kg.
The lowest price has
remained at $0,10 for both
at auction and contract
floors. The number of bales
laid this year are 1 104 236
compared to 808 957 laid
during the corresponding
period last year. The sta-
tistics show that bales sold
this year are 1 034 271 an
increase of 36 percent from
731 448 bales sold last year
same period.
The number of bales
rejected are 60 291 which
is a decline from 77 509
rejected bales during the
corresponding period last
year.●
5. BH24 Reporter
HARARE - Ecobank Trans-
national Incorporated (ETI),
parent company of the Eco-
bank Group (which operates
EcoBank Zimbabwe) and Old
Mutual Emerging Markets
have announced an enhanced
bancassurance partnership
arrangement.
Old Mutual Emerging Markets
currently has a bancassur-
ance partnership with the
Ecobank Group.
This latest agreement will
grow the existing strategic
alliance by offering seamless
insurance services to Eco-
bank clients across selected
countries where the two
groups have operations.
In terms of the enhanced
strategic partnership clients
will benefit mutually though
access to a range of finan-
cial services that include life
insurance, savings and short-
term insurance solutions
across a greater network on
the African continent.
Ecobank group CEO Mr Ade
Ayeyemi said plans for the
integrated model include pro-
viding access to Old Mutual
solutions for Ecobank’s
banking operations across
selected countries.
“This is a productive and
valued partnership between
two pan-African institutions
to provide complete finan-
cial services solutions to our
customers,” he said.
Old Mutual Emerging Markets
CEO Mr Ralph Mupita said:“It
is in our mutual interest
to ensure that this alliance
grows from strength to
strength, as we now look to
complement Ecobank’s range
of banking services to its
customers with Old Mutual’s
trusted financial products
across the Ecobank network
on the continent.”
Pan-African banking group,
Ecobank currently has a
presence in 36 African coun-
tries, including Zimbabwe.
And Old Mutual’s Africa
footprint includes operations
in Ghana, Nigeria, Kenya,
Malawi, Namibia, Swaziland,
Zimbabwe, Uganda, Tan-
zania, Rwanda and South
Sudan.●
5 news
Ecobank, Old Mutual announce enhanced bancassurance partnership
7. BH24 Reporter
HARARE - The Government
through the Minister of Tour-
ism and Hospitality Industry
has intensified efforts to
attract more airline to Victo-
ria Falls as a way of increas-
ing capacity at the newly
build Victoria Falls Airport.
Tourism and Hospitality
Industry deputy Minister
Anastacia Ndlovu said that
they were already in dis-
cussion with Turkish airlines
officials to have the airline
introduce direct flights into
Victoria Falls.
“We are negotiating with
Turkish Airlines to operate
the direct flights into resort
town of Victoria Falls.
“There is a business dele-
gation from Turkey which is
coming sometime this month
and we should use that
meeting to also promote our
operations here,” she said.
The deputy minister was
speaking on the sidelines of
the International Air Travel
Association day that was held
in Victoria Falls last week.
She said that attracting more
airlines into Victoria Falls
was key to the success of
airport, which underwent a
multi-million dollar facelift
and expansion at a cost $150
million.
“We’ve completed the refur-
bishment of Victoria Falls
International Airport, but we
don’t want it to be a white
elephant, so besides Turk-
ish Airlines Ltd., we are also
negotiating with other long
haul flights to come here,”
she said.
Some of the features of the
upgraded airport include
an expanded runway that
is now four kilometres long
from 1,5 kilometres, which
allows it to accommodate
long haul jets and a new
terminal that can handle
1,2 million passengers per
annum up from 500 000. ●
Govt intensifies efforts to market Victoria Falls
7 news
8. BH24 Reporter
HARARE- The Institute of
Chartered Secretaries and
Administrators in Zimbabwe
(ICSAZ) has introduced an
affiliate scheme for corporate
governance professionals who
carry out company secretarial,
risk, compliance, accounting
and administration related work
but do not hold the ICSA qual-
ification.
ICSAZ chief executive Dr Farai
Musamba said the scheme is
designed to provide support
structures for people engaged
in corporate governance,
administration and account-
ing-related duties who need
professional support but are not
chartered secretaries.
“It will provide a professional
home for those who are cur-
rently involved in the profes-
sional sector covered by the
Institute,” he said. He added
that this professional support
should help the affiliates per-
form better in their roles.
“This is in line with ICSAZ’s
mission to promote and
advance efficient administration
in commerce, industry and the
public sector,” he said.
Dr Musamba explained that
participation in the scheme
would not accord the affiliates
ICSAZ membership, that is, it
would not allow them to use the
post nominal ACIS or FCIS nor
would it give them chartered
secretary status.
However, the affiliates would be
allowed to describe themselves
as Affiliates of ICSAZ.
He said the initiative to intro-
duce the scheme was taken
after noticing the high number
of people operating in corporate
governance related work who
wished to be associated with a
professional body.
A number of these professionals
had approached the institute
with proposals for an affiliate
scheme, but these proposals
could not be effected previously
due to constitutional issues.
“These constitutional issues
were recently addressed
through the gazetting of the
new chartered secretaries
by-laws,” he said.
Anyone carrying out company
secretarial work, accounting
or other governance, risk and
compliance roles or allied work
to the satisfaction of the ICSAZ
council can become an affiliate
of ICSAZ.
“Other people who can qualify
for the scheme include those
who have been appointed by
companies as secretaries pur-
suant to Section 173A of the
Companies Act,” he added.
Members of other constitu-
ent bodies forming the Public
Accountants and Auditors Board
(PAAB) who are practising as
company secretaries or govern-
ance and compliance profes-
sionals are also eligible.
Those who studied but did not
complete the ICSA programme
and lawyers who are working
as company secretaries but are
not chartered secretaries also
qualify to become affiliates.
ICSAZ is a division of the global
United Kingdom-based Institute
of Chartered Secretaries and
Administrators with a mandate
to promote good corporate
governance and compliance
through the efficient adminis-
tration of commerce, industry
and the public sector.
The ICSA qualification is an
all-round business qualifica-
tion which enables one to be
employed in various capaci-
ties that include accounting,
finance, administration, general
management, tax, informa-
tion technology and human
resources.
●
8 news
ICSAZ sets up affiliate scheme for governance professionals
9. HARARE -After closing Friday
in the red, the mainstream
industrial index opened the
new week in similar territory,
closing at 105.10 points fol-
lowing a 0.70 loss on the back
of key heavyweight losses.
Conglomerate Innscor
weighed on the index the
most with a $0, 0150 drop to
trade at $0, 2200 and giant
beverages producer Delta
eased $0,0067 to close at
$0,7183.
Other losses were in tel-
ecoms firm Econet which
shed $0, 0038 to $0,2162,
giant insurer Old Mutual was
$0,0025 lower at $2,1875 and
FBC lost $0,0010 to close at
$0,0660.
Three counters traded in
positive territory. Meikles was
$0,0080 firmer at $0,0780,
Fidelity Life added $0,0010 to
close at $0,1040 and Nat-
Foods was up by $0,0005 to
trade at $2,1000.
The mining index was flat at
25.19 as Bindura, Falgold,
Hwange and RioZim main-
tained previous price levels at
$0,0120, $0,0050, $0,0300
and $0,1565 respectively
. BH24 Reporter ●
Heavyweights weigh on index as week opens
9 zse
02 03
ADD TO CART
Save big on selected
Products of your choice
PAYMENT
You can purchase
whenever, wherever
using:
DELIVERY
Spend $30 or more
on your purchases
and get free
delivery
01 Hello Convenience
www.hammerandtongues.com
BIG CONVENIENCE+
BIG SAVINGS+
BIG OPPORTUNITIES
= BIG HAPPINESS
SHOP ONLINE!!
11. 11 DIARY OF EVENTS
The black arrow indicate level of load shedding across the country.
POWER GENERATION STATS
Gen Station
23 May 2016
Energy
(Megawatts)
Hwange 471 MW
Kariba 485 MW
Harare 15 MW
Munyati 28 MW
Bulawayo 24 MW
Imports 0 - 400 MW
Total 1360 MW
24 MAY -- Mashonaland Holdings Annual General Meeting; Place: 44 Tilbury Road, Willowvale, Harare, Zimbabwe; Time:
15:00hrs
26 MAY -- Proplastics Annual General Meeting; Place: Meikles Hotel, Cnr 3rd/Jason Moyo Avenue, Harare; Time: 10:00hrs
27 MAY -- ZB Financial Holdings Limited Twenty-Seventh Annual General Meeting; Place: Board Room, Ground Floor, 21
Natal Road, Avondale, Harare; Time: 10:30hrs
31 MAY -- Pearl Properties (2006) Limited Annual General Meeting; Place: Royal Harare Golf Club, Harare; Time: 14.30hrs
2 JUNE -- Zimplow Annual General Meeting; Place: Zimplow Holdings Limited Head Office, 36 Birmingham Road, Harare;
Time: 10:00hrs
9 JUNE -- First Mutual Holdings Annual General Meeting; Place: Royal Harare Golf Club, Harare; Time: 14:30hrs
THE BH24 DIARY
12. JOHANNESBURG - South
Africa's rand strengthened
early on Monday after the
police said they had no plans
to arrest Finance Minister
Pravin Gordhan over his role
in the formation of a surveil-
lance unit within the revenue
service.
At 0700 GMT the rand had
edged 0,2 percent firmer to
15,6050 per dollar.
Bonds were also firmer in
early trade, with the yield on
the benchmark government
issue due in 2026 cutting 6
basis points to 9,33 percent.
The elite Hawks police unit
told Reuters it had no plans
to arrest Gordhan as part
of an investigation into a
surveillance unit set up by
the revenue service during
his time in charge. Gord-
han headed the tax agency
between 1999 to 2009.
Numerous political upheav-
als since President Jacob
Zuma's shock sacking of then
Finance Minister Nhlanhla
Nene in December have seen
the rand suffer.
Traders said the rand would
benefit if political tensions
around the finance minister
eased.
"The rand has rebounded
somewhat since hitting all-
time lows in thin liquidity
during mid-January, aided
by hawkish action from the
SARB (South African Reserve
Bank) and generally calmer
emerging markets," analysts
at NKC Africa Economics said
in a note.
"However, further gains will
be difficult given the height-
ened political risk environ-
ment."
The rand has gained more
than 1,5 percent against the
greenback since slipping to
a new one-month low after
last week’s decision by the
central bank to keep lending
rates unchanged at 7 per-
cent.
Stocks opened weaker, with
the benchmark Top-40 index
shedding 0,38 percent to
46,356 points by 0708 GMT -
Reuters●
regioNAL News12
Rand gains after police say have no plans to arrest finmin
13. Bayer AG made an unsolic-
ited $62 billion all-cash offer
to acquire Monsanto Co. and
create the world’s biggest
supplier of farm chemicals
and genetically modified
seeds, disclosing the terms
of its bid amid investors’
growing concern that it
might overpay.
Bayer offered $122 per share
in an all-cash bid in its May
10 written proposal, the
Leverkusen-based com-
pany said in a statement on
Monday. That’s a 37 percent
premium to Monsanto’s May
9 closing price. The payment
would be funded with a com-
bination of debt and equity,
with about 25 percent of the
enterprise value coming from
selling shares to existing
investors. Shares of Bayer
dropped to its lowest in more
than 2 1/2 years.
The proposal gives investors
insights into Chief Executive
Officer Werner Baumann’s
style and ambitions as he
attempts to pull off the big-
gest corporate takeover ever
by a German company after
less than a month at the
helm. Buying St. Louis-based
Monsanto would give Bayer
the world’s largest seed sup-
plier and a pioneer of crop
biotechnology. The kind of
genetically modified seeds
that Monsanto started to
sell two decades ago now
account for the majority of
corn and soybeans grown in
the US.
The two companies are
engaged in “constructive
discussions,” the CEO said.
Bayer fell 3,4 percent to
86.48 euros, the lowest since
October 2013, as of 9:07
a.m. in Frankfurt trading.
‘Uneducated Reaction’
Bayer’s stock had plunged
by the most in seven years
when it confirmed having
made an offer, without dis-
closing the financial details,
on Thursday. Monsanto
hasn’t responded to the offer
publicly, beyond saying that
it was reviewing the terms.
“What we saw last week
was an uneducated reaction
in the media and the press
because we did not com-
municate the details of our
proposal,” Baumann said on
a conference call on Monday.
“We are utterly convinced of
the rationale” of the pro-
posal.
The deal will add to core
earnings per share by a mid-
single-digit percentage in the
first full year after com-
pletion, and a double-digit
percentage thereafter, Bayer
said. The German company
also expects earnings to be
bolstered by savings of about
$1,5 billion from the fourth
year following the deal.
Role Reversal
The offer marks a reversal
of roles for Monsanto. The
company previously sought
to buy Swiss pesticide maker
Syngenta AG, but had to
abandon the $43,7 billion
bid in August after the other
company refused to agree to
a deal.
The crop and seed indus-
try is being reshaped by a
series of large transactions.
China National Chemical
Corp. agreed in February to
acquire Syngenta for about
$43 billion, months after
Monsanto abandoned its own
bid. Meanwhile DuPont Co.
and Dow Chemical Co. plan
to merge and then carve out
a new crop-science unit.
Bank of America Corp. and
Credit Suisse Group AG
are the financing banks for
Bayer, while Rothschild has
been retained as an addi-
tional financial adviser. –
Bloomberg●
internatioNAL News13
Germany’s Bayer offers $62 billion in cash to buy Monsanto
14. By Dianna Games
Mistrust between the private
sector and governments in
Africa is one of the biggest
impediments to the delivery
of infrastructure, the CEO of
a South African multinational
company says.
This issue has dogged Afri-
can development for many
years — suspicion and even
animosity between the two
"sides", whose strategic
collaboration is critical to
delivering better lives for
Africans.
At various pan-African events
I have attended in the past
few weeks, the private
sector, when mentioned at
all, has been characterised
largely as "the enemy".
Talk about development
in organisations such as
the African Union and UN
Economic Commission for
Africa (UNECA) tend to place
the state at the centre of
everything. The private sec-
tor is viewed as an unreliable
14 analysis14 analysis
Public-private sector mistrust undermining Africa’s progress
15. 15 analysis15 analysis
adjunct, focused on exploit-
ing Africans rather than pro-
viding any benefits to people
or the state.
Although the mistrust issue
has been around for a long
time, it has been given new
impetus in the corridors of
continental power by the
findings of the AU’s high-
level panel on illicit financial
flows, which estimates that
$60bn a year is leaving the
continent illicitly, a figure
later revised upwards to
$80bn.
Of this, the panel’s report
says, 60 percent derives
from the activities of large
commercial companies in the
form of transfer pricing, tax
dodges, trade misinvoicing
and corruption. Also men-
tioned are tax incentives,
which are not about outflows,
nor are they illicit.
But, the report asserts, they
also rob the continent of
much-needed revenue, with
companies pushing govern-
ments eager for investment
in a race to the bottom. The
actions of large companies
are undermining the ability
of governments to mobilise
domestic resources for devel-
opment, officials say.
UNECA released a report
earlier this year, examin-
ing bilateral treaties African
countries have with other
countries, mostly outside
Africa. The findings sug-
gest governments have been
victims of treaties that tend
to favour the interests of
western nations and their
companies rather than those
of Africans. On the other
side of the coin, many in the
private sector do not trust
governments to serve their
interests and argue that
safeguards are necessary to
guard against high risk, to
deal with the consequences
of poor and unpredictable
policy, and to ensure good
returns in high-cost, corrupt
and inefficient environments.
African economist and devel-
opment specialist Nkosana
Moyo has offered a view on
why suspicion of the pri-
vate sector is so pervasive
in Africa. He says many
Africans view business as
representing the colonial
era and, by extension, their
interests as being those of
foreign nations and not those
of the economies in which
they invest. This makes
true engagement difficult. It
speaks to the fact that few
countries at independence
had a domestic business
sector of any size and most
economies were dominated
by companies from western
colonial powers.
But these stereotypes ignore
several things.
One is the fact that not all
companies in Africa are large
multinationals. Rather, more
than 60 percent of business
in Africa is undertaken by
small, informal entrepre-
neurs.
Another is that Afri-
can-owned companies and
multinationals with a real
stake in domestic economies
are in the ascendancy. And
another is that, while there
are companies that may not
play by the development
rules and may act in ways
that run counter to the inter-
ests of African countries,
there are many more that are
good corporate citizens.
There are many examples
of successful public-private
partnerships across the con-
tinent, often with large west-
ern companies. But these are
seldom raised at conferences
where the private sector is
being cast as the villain and
where business representa-
tives have no voice. The mis-
trust malaise is not helping
efforts to develop Africa — it
is having the opposite effect.
In the end, it is not about
the private sector or govern-
ment interests directly, but
about win-win partnerships
for Africa. – BDLive●
• Games is CEO of busi-
ness advisory Africa @
Work